R290 vs CO2 in Heat Pumps: Why Zero-Carbon Refrigerant R290 is Ideal for UK Homes

Why the Choice of Refrigerant Matters

Picking the right refrigerant isn’t just about filling your system. It defines:
– Your energy bills.
– Your carbon footprint.
– System lifetime and reliability.

In the realm of eco-friendly refrigerants, R290 (propane) and CO2 (carbon dioxide) stand tall. Both are natural, low-GWP champions. Yet they differ in performance, cost and safety.

The Case for R290

R290, aka propane, has surged up the ranks of eco-friendly refrigerants. Here’s why:

• Tiny Global Warming Potential
  GWP of just 3. Near-zero climate impact compared to R410A with GWPs in the thousands.

• Top-Tier Efficiency
  Propane’s thermodynamic properties let heat pumps transfer more heat with less electricity. Like a cheetah on the savannah—fast and efficient.

• Zero Ozone Depletion
  R290’s ODP is 0. Good for our ozone layer.

But wait—there’s a catch. R290 is flammable. That means:
– Strict charge limits (often max 150 g per system).
– Certified instalments and leak detection.
– Ventilation and flame-retardant components.

R290 Highlights

• High Seasonal Coefficient of Performance (SCOP).
• Consistent across a broad temperature range.
• Installation costs typically 5–10% lower than CO2.

R290 Caveats

• Flammability demands extra safety steps.
• Regional limits on refrigerant charge.
• Need for trained engineers.

Understanding CO2

CO2, or R744, is another major player among eco-friendly refrigerants:

• GWP of 1, ODP of 0. Peak sustainability credentials.
• Excellent cold-climate performance: think of CO2 as a heavyweight lifter.
• Abundant, non-toxic and inert.

Downside? High operating pressures. That means:
– Reinforced pipes and valves.
– Specialised components.
– Higher upfront cost and expert maintenance.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Both beat traditional refrigerants by miles. But the best fit depends on:
– UK temperature patterns.
– Budget vs long-term savings.
– Compliance with local safety rules.
– Technician availability.

Safety and Regulations

Regulations exist for a reason. Under EU F-gas rules (and UK equivalents):

• R290:
  • Charge ≤ 150 g in most domestic units.
  • Leak detectors and ventilation systems.
  • Certified installers.

• CO2:
  • High-pressure rated equipment only.
  • Pressure relief valves.
  • Specialized maintenance training.

Skipping compliance isn’t an option. That’s why The Heat Pumps UK provides expert installation and maintenance services. We keep your new eco-friendly refrigerants system safe, legal and running flawlessly.

Cost vs Efficiency

Money matters. Here’s a simple breakdown:

• Installation
  R290: 5–10% cheaper upfront.
  CO2: Higher cost for reinforced components.

• Operating Costs
  R290: Low electricity draw—great for mild climates.
  CO2: Saves up to 15% in long winters thanks to cold-climate efficiency.

• Government Grants
  UK schemes reward low-GWP heat pumps. R290 and CO2 installations qualify. Explore our grants guidance for the latest deals.

Rough ROI:
– R290 pays back in 4–6 years in typical UK conditions.
– CO2 breaks even in 5–7 years if you face frequent sub-zero spells.

Get a personalised quote

Why R290 Suits UK Homes

UK winters? Chilly, not Arctic. R290 checks more boxes:

• Peak performance around 0–10 °C.
• Lower installation outlay.
• Growing market brings down prices.
• Government grants + flexible finance ease the upfront spend.

Picture this: a near-silent system, using minimal energy, powered by eco-friendly refrigerants. No gas bills. No large carbon footprint. Just warm rooms and lower bills.

We back every R290 install with:
– Tailored system design.
– Expert installation and maintenance services.
– Flexible finance options.
– Grant application support.

It’s heating made simple. And green.

Final Thoughts

Both R290 and CO2 are stars in the eco-friendly refrigerants universe. For most UK homes, R290 is the practical pick:

• Ultra-low GWP with zero ODP.
• Competitive efficiency in mild to cool climates.
• Lower upfront cost.
• Manageable safety protocols.

CO2 shines in industrial or super-cold settings. But for your living room? R290 is the reliable ally.

Ready to switch to zero-carbon, cost-saving heating? Let our team handle the details—from design right through to hand-over.

Start your journey to greener heating